Search
Leave a Message
Thank you for your message. I will be in touch with you shortly.
Explore My Properties
Quiet North Jersey commuter rail platform with a black bench, a stopped stainless-steel train and late-autumn houses and trees beyond the railing.

What Lyndhurst's Commute to Manhattan Looks Like Now

In 2025, the average home sold in Lyndhurst went for $668,096. The average home in Rutherford went for $670,903. The two prices are $2,807 apart, a rounding error on a mortgage. The average 2025 property tax bills were $11,543 in Lyndhurst and $14,063 in Rutherford, and that $2,520 gap comes back every year.

If you commute to Manhattan and you're choosing between these two towns, the tax bill is the number that separates them. The rail improvements that finished over the past year and a half, a new Lyndhurst station in 2025 and a fully working Portal North Bridge this month, improve the commute without changing that comparison.

The Bridge That No Longer Opens

On Monday, November 16, 2026, NJ TRANSIT put rail service back on regular weekday schedules, Main-Bergen County Line included. That ended the second track cutover on the Portal North Bridge. The final cutover work started October 9. From October 11 through November 14, riders had adjusted schedules, with consolidated trains, cancellations and changed stops. The first track had carried passengers since March 16, 2026.

The new span crosses the Hackensack River between Kearny and Secaucus on two tracks set about 50 feet above the water. It is fixed, so boats pass under it and the bridge never has to swing open. NJ TRANSIT describes the payoff as fewer bridge-related delays and a more resilient corridor. Amtrak reported on October 29 that the old swing bridge had been handed over for demolition, and NJ TRANSIT's March announcement said it would be taken apart in 2027.

Weekends still have one leftover. NJ TRANSIT's schedule page warns that some weekends through December 2026 may see delays of up to 20 minutes during final testing, so check before a Saturday trip into the city for a holiday show.

One Station on Court Avenue

The bridge is the second change to the Lyndhurst commute in two years. The first one changed where in town you can walk to a train.

Until June 8, 2025, Lyndhurst had two Main Line stops. Kingsland station was at 250 Ridge Road in the downtown business district, and the old Lyndhurst station sat between Court and Stuyvesant avenues. NJ.com described them as about a three-minute drive apart. At an August 2024 public meeting, News 12 New Jersey reported that most speakers opposed closing Kingsland. NJ TRANSIT pointed to Kingsland's lack of ADA access, stair-only platforms, missing elevator and inadequate parking. The plan NJ.com reported was to close the Kingsland platforms to the public and keep the building for rail operations storage and maintenance.

The replacement is the new Lyndhurst station at 366 Court Avenue, just east of the old one. It has high-level platforms, elevators, stairs and canopies, and the building was designed to echo the neighborhood's historic style. The Federal Transit Administration paid $30.9 million toward it, and it replaced a station more than a century old. NJ TRANSIT lists 470 standard parking spaces and 10 accessible ones, with no parking fee, plus a ticket vending machine on the platform. In the agency's release, Mayor Robert Giangeruso said the station "is poised to become one of the busiest transit hubs in Bergen County." The agency counted more than 800 weekday passenger trips at the station.

For anyone house hunting in the Ridge Road part of town, the practical change is the walk. A block that used to be a stroll to Kingsland is now a drive or a shuttle ride from the train. The township said EZ Ride would extend its weekday peak-hour Rutherford–Lyndhurst shuttle to stop at the new station, which links it to the Kingsland area. On a showing, time the trip from the front door to the Court Avenue platform, because a listing's old "near the train" line may have been written about Kingsland.

Six Morning Trains in Each Town

The Main/Bergen County weekday timetable, effective November 15, 2026, has six Lyndhurst departures toward Hoboken and New York before 8:30 a.m.: 5:40, 6:08, 6:59, 7:27, 8:01 and 8:29. These trains run on the Main Line. Rutherford's station is on the Bergen County Line and also has six departures in that window: 5:51, 6:14, 6:41, 7:10, 7:46 and 8:11. Its next one leaves at 8:52.

The two towns trade spacing, not volume. Lyndhurst has a 51-minute gap between 6:08 and 6:59, and Rutherford has nothing that long before 8:11. From 7:27 on, Lyndhurst runs trains roughly every half hour. If your office expects you at 9:00, the morning train count doesn't separate these towns. The time you need to leave the house does.

The fastest example in the timetable leaves Lyndhurst at 5:40, reaches Secaucus Junction at 5:48, connects to a 5:54 train and arrives at New York Penn at 6:07. That's 27 minutes, transfer included. Later departures have longer waits at Secaucus, so treat 27 minutes as the low end of a range. The same timetable also lists direct Hoboken arrivals for PATH riders.

Bus commuters have another option. NJ TRANSIT's New York route list includes the 192, Clifton–New York, and the 199, Clifton–Lyndhurst–New York, which runs weekday peak hours only. Check the stop closest to any address you're considering before you count on either route.

Same Price, Different Bill

With the trains this close, the money comparison is the clearest difference between the towns. The figures below come from the state's 2025 Average Residential Statistics, the latest full year published. They are averages, not medians.

Town 2025 average sale price 2025 average residential tax bill
Lyndhurst $668,096 $11,543
Rutherford $670,903 $14,063
North Arlington $638,440 $11,442

In 2025, buyers paid essentially the same price in Lyndhurst and Rutherford even though Rutherford's average tax bill was $2,520 higher. Over ten years at that gap, a Lyndhurst owner would pay roughly $25,000 less in property tax on a home that cost about the same to buy. A market that fully priced the tax difference would put Lyndhurst's purchase prices below Rutherford's. In 2025 it did not. Whatever Rutherford's premium was paying for, the current timetables give both towns the same number of early trains. The difference could be Rutherford's walkable downtown, its housing stock or its school-year routines, and only a buyer can weigh those. Our Rutherford vs. Lyndhurst vs. East Rutherford comparison covers that side.

North Arlington is the third option. In 2025 its average tax bill was close to Lyndhurst's and its average sale price was about $30,000 lower. If you'll ride the train every day, compare how far each address is from its closest platform before you compare prices.

For context on the current market, NJ REALTORS' Bergen County report for October 2026 shows a single-family median sale price of $880,000. Those homes sold in an average of 39 days for 102.0% of list price. Townhouses and condos had a $582,000 median and 43 days on market that month. These figures cover the whole county and use medians, so they aren't directly comparable to the town averages above. Even so, both Lyndhurst and Rutherford sit well below the county's single-family median. Tax figures here are 2025 averages for general information only. They are not tax, legal or financial advice, so confirm any specific property's bill with the right professional.

What Ridge Road Becomes

With Kingsland closed, the Ridge Road business district no longer has a train station, and the township has been working on what happens there next. Lyndhurst's 2024 Master Plan Reexamination traces a 2010 designation of eleven Ridge Road parcels and a vacant train station as an area in need of redevelopment, an effort called "Project Tomorrow." No redevelopment plan was ever adopted for it. The report recommends a fresh study of those Ridge Road lots and suggests exploring redevelopment along Stuyvesant Avenue and Valley Brook Avenue too. These are recommendations, not approved projects.

One project already has approval. The township's Fourth Round Housing Element, adopted June 16, 2025, lists 18 units at 251–255 Ridge Road, three of them affordable, and described the project as under construction when the plan was adopted. For a buyer looking at Ridge Road blocks, the zoning work ahead matters more than the commute. If you also want a weekend route along the marsh, our DeKorte Park walk guide maps the trails that are open now.

Quick Answers

Does Kingsland station still have trains? No. Service moved to the new Lyndhurst station on June 8, 2025, and Kingsland closed that day.

Is parking at the Lyndhurst station free? NJ TRANSIT lists no parking fee for the station's 470 standard and 10 accessible spaces.

Are weekend trains back to normal after the Portal work? Weekday schedules returned November 16, 2026. Some weekends through December 2026 may still see delays of up to 20 minutes during final testing.

If you're choosing between Lyndhurst and Rutherford, the comparison that settles it is one address against another, with each home's trip to its platform and its own tax bill. Ask Agent Alexa and schedule your free market consultation, or start with our Lyndhurst neighborhood page.

Follow Me On Instagram